Fantasy football awards and trophy ideas: 25 league awards with a witch's verdict
The season is not over until the awards are handed out. Here are 25 awards for the end of the year, from glory to shame, plus 10 trophy ideas for the champion and the last place team.
Glory awards: 8 fantasy football awards
The ones people actually want to win.
- League Champion. The trophy, the glory and a lifetime of bringing it up at weddings.
- Runner-Up. Lost the final. Gets a small plaque and the right to say "I was robbed" for the rest of the year.
- Most Points For. Scored more than anyone and still might not win. The luck of the schedule is its own curse.
- Best Record. Won the most games in the regular season. Doubles as the "choked in the playoffs" favorite.
- Best Draft. Whose Week 1 roster aged the best? Award it to the manager with the best total value from the original draft.
- Waiver Wire Wizard. The manager who found the most points on the free agent list. Bonus spell points for picking up a star before anyone noticed.
- The Trade Shark. Won a trade so badly the other manager is still wondering what happened. The commissioner reviewed it and found nothing illegal, only sad.
- Highest Single Week Score. One glorious Sunday where everything went right. The witch calls it a clerical error.
Shame awards: 9 fantasy football awards
For the season in review that nobody wants to be in.
- Last Place (The Cauldron Spoon). Finished at the bottom. Earns the stirring spoon, the punishment and the sympathy of nobody.
- Most Points Against. Opponents scored the most on this team every week. It is not the manager's fault. It is also entirely the manager's fault.
- Unluckiest Manager. Highest points scored among teams that missed the playoffs. Lost the most games they "should" have won. The witch shed a single tear.
- Luckiest Manager. Best record relative to points scored. Won games by scoring less than the opponent's bench. Do not ask how.
- Biggest Bench Blunder. The most points left on the bench in a single week. Award it with a printout of the lineup.
- The Auto-Draft Award. Awarded to the manager who clicked the auto-draft button and trusted the algorithm. Often surprisingly good. Never admit that.
- Worst Trade. Gave away a future star for a player who got hurt two days later. Crowd-voted every year, still undefeated.
- Most Dropped and Regretted. Dropped a player in Week 5 who then scored 30 for someone else. Everyone knows. The witch knows.
- The Ghost. Stopped setting a lineup around Week 9. Still showing up in the standings like a very sad poltergeist.
Fun and fan-voted awards: 8 fantasy football awards
Let the league vote. It becomes the real playoff.
- Best Team Name. Voted by the league. The winner gets a free name change next season.
- Best Trash Talk. The funniest message of the year. Collect the receipts in the group chat and vote.
- Best GIF Game. The manager who always has the perfect reaction GIF ready. A rare and valuable talent.
- Most Improved. Finished the season far higher than they started. A comeback story fit for a documentary.
- The Rivalry Award. The pair of managers who produced the best head-to-head drama of the year. Both get a plaque and a restraining order.
- Best Comeback. Won a matchup after trailing on Sunday night and winning on Monday night. The witch calls it a miracle, the loser calls it witchcraft.
- Most Hexed Manager. The one whose players got cursed the most, on the Fantasy Witch hex board or in the group chat.
- The Commissioner's Choice. A catch-all award the commish gives to whoever amused them most. Corruption, but make it fun.
Fantasy football trophy ideas
Some for the champion. Some for the person who finished last.
- The Cauldron Cup. A real cauldron-shaped trophy. Fill it with candy for the winner and eye of newt for the loser.
- The traveling trophy. The champion keeps it all year, then ships it to the next winner. The shipping label is part of the lore.
- The championship belt. A wrestling belt for the league champion. The group chat will require a photo in it every week.
- The engraved plaque on a shared base. One trophy, a new nameplate each year. The history of the league in brass.
- The golden toilet seat. For last place. Painted gold. Mounted proudly. Pairs with the toilet bowl.
- The wooden spoon. The classic last place award. Cheap, humiliating and durable, like most bad decisions.
- The broken trophy. A trophy that was dropped on purpose and glued. Awarded to the Most Points Against.
- The custom jersey. A jersey with the champion's name and the year. The loser wears one with "LAST" on the back.
- The champion's banner. A banner that hangs in the group chat photo. Updated every season by whoever has a printer.
- The trophy that insults you. A trophy for the loser with a ridiculous inscription. "Almost" and "Next year" are both excellent.
How to run a fantasy football awards show
- Announce the awards at the start of the season so everyone knows what they are playing for.
- Use real data where you can: points for, points against, waiver pickups, and the commissioner's own receipts.
- Let the league vote on anything subjective, and use a tiebreaker for the funny categories.
- Post the winners with a Fantasy Witch share card for each, in the group chat, on the same day.
- Keep one running list in the pinned message so next year's winners know what they are chasing.
🔮 Win the league first: curse your opponent
More: last place punishments · playoff trash talk · league names · superstitions
FAQ
What are good fantasy football league awards?
The classics are League Champion, Most Points For, Best Draft and Last Place. Add shame awards like Biggest Bench Blunder and Unluckiest Manager, and fun ones like Best Team Name and Best Trash Talk, voted by the league.
When should I give out fantasy football awards?
Right after the championship game, or the week after the toilet bowl. Posting them while the group chat is still fired up gets the most reactions.
What is a good fantasy football trophy?
A traveling trophy that the winner keeps for a year, a championship belt, or a custom cauldron cup. For last place, the wooden spoon and the golden toilet seat are the classics.
What is the toilet bowl trophy?
The toilet bowl is the consolation bracket for the worst teams. Its trophy is usually a golden toilet seat or plunger for the last place finisher, handed out with plenty of ceremony.
How do I pick the winners of the fun awards?
Let the league vote in the group chat with a poll, and use the commissioner as the tiebreaker. Keep the voting open for a day and expect arguments.